63 Orchard Street, Margaretville, NY 12455

$250,000
1
BD
2
BA
1,720
SqFt

Show Photos

Verify your account to unlock exclusive photos, mortgage tools, and more.

Sold Price
$250,000
List Price
$250,000
Status
CLOSED
Days on Market
18
Closing Date
Nov 25, 2025
MLS#
20253719
Subtype
Residential
Style
Other
Year Built
1920
Bedrooms
1
Bathrooms
2
Full Baths
1
Half Baths
1
Living Area
1,720
Lot Size
9,583
Acres
0.22
MLS Area Major
Middletown

Property Description

History meets modern comfort in this rare Catskills find. Built in 1931 as St. Margaret's Chapel, this thoughtfully updated loft-like residence blends small-scale charm with flexible, open-plan living. Soaring ceilings, tall English rolled-glass windows, and the dramatic double-door entry set the stage for a truly one-of-a-kind home or getaway. Inside, the main level flows from a sunlit open living/dining area to a versatile stage-like alcove ideal for a kitchen expansion, creative workspace, or art studio. Recent upgrades include a full bath, kitchenette, mini-split heating/cooling, and a private back patio for outdoor dining. A set of steps (or a future interior staircase) leads to the lower level, where the next owner could envision bedrooms, a media lounge, or workshop space - perfect for those who love a (manageable) project. The building's intimate scale and adaptable footprint will appeal to fans of historic architecture, small-house living, or anyone seeking something truly unique. Outside enjoy a manicured lawn with established landscaping, a new patio area, a fire-pit and the most inviting hammock! Two off-street parking spaces and a flat level yard perfect for entertaining. Located on a quiet village street, you're minutes to Margaretville's shops, cafes, and year-round Catskills recreation. Public water/sewer for low-maintenance living. If you've been searching for a property that inspires conversation the moment you open the door - this is it. Your (incredibly unique) Catskill Dream Awaits!

Additional Information

Interior Features
High Ceilings
Exterior Features
Fire Pit
Taxes
$2,218
Property Description
Other
Zoning
124603
Flooring
Concrete, Wood
Air Conditioning
Other
Roof
Shingle
School District
Margaretville Central Schools
View
Mountain(s)

Mortgage Calculator

Amount of Loan
Annual Interest Rate
%
Term of Loan
Years

Does not include any taxes or fees.
Please consult a financial professional.
Calculator source: Real Geeks

Listing courtesy of Listing Agent: Margaret Bellar () from Listing Office: The Catskill Dream Team.

Selling Office: .